Well, I went today and
saw the latest “Hellboy” adaptation. However, before I talk about how I feel on
that, I should probably talk about the ones that came before it, even though
this is another origin movie. Let’s start off with the 2004 adaptation of “Hellboy.”
This is one of those
rare movies that’s not only based on a comic book, but also feels like a comic
book. It’s filled with energy, and you can feel the passion and joy when they
made it. Obviously it’s made of wildly special effects, weird makeup and a ridiculous
story line, but it follows through everything lightly. Unlike some CGI movies
that drag from one point to another, this one skips cheerfully through the
action.
With Ron Perlman, they
have found actor who is not just playing a superhero, but enjoying it.
Obviously he, knowingly, had to go through hours in makeup every day; he smokes
his cigar, wags his tail and fights his villains with something approaching delight.
You can see an actor in the process of making a difficult character really
work.
The movie, based on
comics by Mike Mignola and directed by the great Mexican horror man Guillermo
del Toro, starts with a scene that has Nazis, those most strong of comic book
villains. In a hopeless time late in World War II, they open a portal to the
dark side and bring forth the Seven Gods of Chaos – almost do, before they are
caught by U.S. soldiers and Professor Bruttenholm, played by John Hurt, who is
President Roosevelt’s personal psychic adviser. Nothing gets past the portal
except a little red baby with horns and a tail. He is vicious towards the
professor, who calms him with a Baby Ruth bar, comforts him in his arms and
raises him to become human’s main call against the demons of Satan’s home.
Meanwhile, the psychic
practitioner Grigori Rasputin, played by Karel Roden, who is working for the
Nazis, is pulled into the portal and disappears. Yes, he’s the same Rasputin.
We skip to the present
day. The professor, now in his 80s, is told he will die soon. Two of his old
enemies are strangely still the same age, however: a Nazi named Ilsa (Bridget Hodson)
and a strange person named Korenen (Ladislav Beran), who is addicted to
surgical fixes on his body. In an icy area in Mondavia, they hold celebrations
to bring Rasputin back from the other side, and they’re ready to start.
Now we’re at a secret FBI
headquarters where Hellboy lives with the professor and an aquatic being named
Abe Sapien, played by Doug Jones – a fishman who got his name because he was
born the day Abraham Lincoln was assassinated. The professor is teaching a
young FBI agent Clay, played by Corey Johnson, when the Nazis attack a museum
and free a creation imprisoned inside an ancient statue. Roger Ebert described
this creature in his review as “a writhing, repellent, oozing mass of tentacles
and teeth, reproduces by dividing and will soon conquer the Earth unless
Hellboy can come to the rescue.”
Obviously he does that
in action scenes that seem on the storyboard coming directly from pages of a
comic book. Ebert said, “Hellboy gets banged up a lot but is somehow able to
pick himself up off the mat and repair himself with a little self-applied
chiropractic; a crunch of his spine, a pop of his shoulders and he's back in
action.”
Ebert continued, “Abe
the fishboy, who wears a breathing apparatus out of the water, is more of a
dreamer than a fighter, with a personality that makes him a distant relative of
Jar-Jar Binks.”
Hellboy has a lonely life.
Ebert said, “When you are 7 feet tall and bright red with a tail, you don't
exactly fit in, even though HB tries to make himself look more normal by sawing
his horns down to stumps, which he sands every morning. He is in love with
another paranormal, Liz Sherman (Selma Blair), a pyrokineticist who feels
guilty because she starts fires when she gets excited.” There is a great scene
where Hellboy kisses her and she enters flames, and we see they are made for
one another because, as we know, Hellboy is fireproof.
The FBI, which is once
in a while blamed for not sharing its information with other agencies, keeps
Hellboy as its own deep secret. That funny actor Jeffrey Tambor plays the FBI
chief, an administrator who is just not made to fight the demons of Satan’s
home. He has some funny set-up scenes, and of course the movie is best when it’s
making every character and before it leads up to its apocalyptic battles.
Hellboy fights the
monsters in subway tunnels and subterranean caverns, as Liz, Clay and Abe the
fishman go with him. Ebert said, “I know, of course, that one must accept the
action in a movie like this on faith, but there was one transition I was
utterly unable to follow. Liz has saved
them all from the monsters by filling a cave with fire, which shrivels them and
their eggs into crispy s'mores, and then -- well, the movie cuts directly to
another cave in which they are held captive by the evil Nazis, and Hellboy is
immobilized in gigantic custom-made stocks that has an extra-large hole for his
oversized left hand.” How did that happen?
Ebert said, “Never
mind. Doesn't matter. Despite his sheltered upbringing, Hellboy has somehow
obtained the tough-talking personality of a Brooklyn stevedore, but he has a
tender side, not only for Liz but for cats and kittens. He has one scene with
the FBI director that reminded me of the moment when Frankenstein enjoys a cigar
with the blind man.” He always lights his stogies with a lighter, and Tambor
explains that cigars must always be lit with a wooden match. That’s good to
know when Liz isn’t around.
Next came the 2008
sequel, “Hellboy II: The Golden Army.” Imagine the fires of Satan’s home mixed
with the alien in Mos Eisley on Tatooine, and you have a feeling of Guillermo
del Toro’s sequel. This is in every way equal to the first movie, maybe a
little nosier; it’s another work of his passion for strange fantasy and deadly
machines. The sequel avoids the details of Hellboy’s origin story, but adds a
story told to him as a child by his adoptive father, where we see an ancient
fight between humans and everything else: trolls, monsters, goblins, the Tooth
Fairy, everything.
There was a piece. The
humans got the cities, and the trolls got the forests. But humans have cheated
on their end of the deal by building parking lots and shopping malls, and now
Prince Nuada, played by Luke Goss, disobeys his father the king and hopes to
start the fight again. This would involve awakening the Golden Army: 70 times
70 sleeping emotionless fighters. Standing against this decision is his twin
sister, Princess Nuala, played by Anna Walton.
Ebert said, “And so on.
I had best not get bogged down in plot description, except to add that Hellboy
(Ron Perlman) and his sidekicks fight for the human side.” His colleagues
include Abe Sapien, somewhat of a fight-man, the fire-generating Liz Sherman, a
Teutonic advisor named Johann Kraus, voiced by the creator of "Family Guy," "American Dad" and "The Cleveland Show," (who also provides the voice of Peter Griffin, Brian Griffin, Stewie Griffin, Glenn Quagmire, Tom Tucker, Carter Pewterschmidt, Dr. Hartman, Jasper, Seamus Levine, Ida Davis, Stan Smith and Roger) Seth MacFarlane, and obviously
Princess Nuala. Tom Manning (Tambor) from the secret center for telepathic insight joins
them, but isn’t a lot of help, except for adding unimportance and dismissive sideways.
Ebert said, “Now that
we have most of the characters onstage, let me describe the sights, which are
almost all created by CGI, of course, but how else?” There’s a climactic fight
between Hellboy and the Prince, with the Golden Army standing inactive, in what
looks like the engine room of Satan’s home. Giant joining gears go up against
each other for no real purpose, expect to ruin Hellboy or anything else that
falls into them. Lucky they aren’t completely adjusted.
Ebert said, “There are
also titanic battles in the streets of Manhattan involving gigantic
octo-creatures and so on, but you know what? Although they're well done,
titanic battles in the streets of Manhattan are becoming commonplace in the
movies these days. What fascinates me is what the octo-creature transformed
itself into, which was unexpected and really lovely. You'll see.”
Ebert continued, “The
towering creatures fascinated me less, however, than some smaller ones. For
example, swarms of tens of thousands of calcium-eaters, who devour humans both
skin and bone and are the source of the Tooth Fairy legend. They pour out of
the walls of an auction house and attack the heroes, and in my personal
opinion, Hellboy is wasting his time trying to shoot them one at a time.”
Ebert goes on, “I also
admire the creativity that went into the Troll Market (it has a secret entry under
the Brooklyn Bridge). Here I think del Toro actually was inspired by the
Tatooine saloon in "Star Wars," and brings together creatures of
fantastical shapes and sizes, buying and selling goods of comparable shapes and
sizes.” It would be worth buying the DVD just to look at it a frame at a time,
finding out what secrets he may have hidden in there. The movies only rarely
give us a fully new kind of place to look at. This will become a classic.
When you look at it,
there are other hints of the “Star Wars” influence in “Hellboy II.” Princess
Nuala doesn’t have Princess Leia’s type of hair (just ordinary long blond
tresses), but she’s not a long way off from her. Also, Abe Sapien looks, moves
and somewhat sounds a lot like C3PO that you’d think the robot became a
fish-like being. Ebert said, “I also noticed hints of John Williams' "Star
Wars" score in the score by Danny Elfman, especially during the final
battle.” Not a aggressive job, you see. More of a suggestion of mood.
What else? Ebert said, “Two
love stories, which I'll leave for you to find out about. And the duet
performance of a song that is rather unexpected, to say the least.” Also once
again we have a great performance by Ron Perlman as Hellboy. Yes, he’s CGI for
the most part, but his face and voice and movements occupy the screen, and make
him one of the great superheroes. Del Toro, who before “Hellboy II” did “Pan’s
Labyrinth” and the great “Blade II,” had followed up this with “Doctor Strange”
and “The Hobbit.” He has so much inventive imagination, and understands how
legends work, why they fascinate us and that they sometimes stand for
something, like love.
Now we come to the 2019
remake of “Hellboy,” which came out four days ago. You will never realize how
much you need Guillermo del Toro to make more movies until you see this reboot.
Christy Lemire said in
her review, “Long gone are the master filmmaker’s stylistic signatures: his
meticulous eye for detail in the biggest monster and tiniest fairy, his deft
tonal balance of the weird and the whimsical, and—above all else—an obvious
affection for his creatures, both good and evil. Instead, under the watch of
director Neil Marshall, we get empty bombast and a million bloody ways to rip a
body to pieces, too few of which are inventive.”
Marshall takes over for
del Toro, who directed the original movie and its sequel, films that were the
perfect pairing of director and actor with Ron Perlman as the wisecracking,
half-demon superhero. Even though it would be tough for anyone to follow in
that great area, Marshall – who mostly has horror films and television credits
to him, including “Game of Thrones” – allowed his look on the character to go
completely out of control.
However, that’s part of
the point. The script from Andrew Cosby, based on Mike Mignola’s Dark Horse
comic series, is defiantly anachronistic and self-aware. It’s also filled with
many flashbacks and digressions introducing more characters and subplots than
anyone could really keep up with. Lemire said, “And this “Hellboy” really
wallows in every last drop of its R-rating whereas the previous films were
PG-13, upping the graphic violence, profanity, and overall gnarliness. It’s the
further Deadpool-ization of an already irreverent and inappropriate character,
and—for a little while—it’s admittedly kind of a kick.”
However, just because a
movie is silly and know its silly, that doesn’t really make its silliness work.
“Hellboy” stops being fun when it stops being funny – when it suddenly turns
into a more harshly bloody, violent mood. Eventually, the film comes to an
extreme point, pathetic madness. Even that might have been fine, however, if
the action scenes where done and staged in a more exciting way. Lemire said, “Instead,
we get crude, computer-generated brutality, choppily edited to the tune of
overplayed rock anthems like Alice Cooper’s “Welcome to My Nightmare” and
Mötley Crüe’s “Kickstart My Heart.””
Lemire continued, “At
the center of it all, the endlessly intriguing and appealing David Harbour can
only do so much. He more than ably steps into Perlman’s giant boots to play the
hulking and hard-drinking Hellboy. It’s good to see the “Stranger Things” star
continue to get leading roles after a lifetime of strong supporting character
work. Harbour has just the right look, the grizzled attitude, the way with a
snappy one-liner.” He even gets the chance to look at Hellboy’s soft side that
is underneath his tough, red façade as the character sees the truth of who he really
is. (Because like stated before, this “Hellboy” is an origin story. Every comic
book hero gets one, and usually more than that.) Lemire said, “But
increasingly, he’s called upon to contribute little more than sheer brute
strength. He’s also stuck with far too many groaners, including one truly
terrible pun toward the end that had me saying: “Oh no, no no no,” out loud to
the screen.”
Where to start with the
story? How about centuries ago, with King Arthur (yes, that King Arthur)
killing the evil blood queen Nimue, played by Milla Jovovich, cutting her body
and placing the parts in boxes to be scattered through the area. (This is just
in the first few minutes.) Fast forward to present day, with Hellboy, as a
member of the Bureau for Paranormal Research and Defense, eventually having to
fight Nimue as she gets put back together and gets her powers to cause destruction
on humans. That is a really truncated explanation of the story. A lot more
happens in this film, but there’s no need to over think this.
Hellboy would look like
a really tough person on himself to battle this ancient villain. However, he
gets help from Sasha Lane of “American Honey,” doing a decent British accent as
a young psychic, Daniel Dae Kim as a British military officer with a secret,
Sophie Okonedo as a noble prophet, and Ian McShane as Professor Broom, or as
Hellboy calls him, Dad. He also has to fight members of a centuries-old best civilization,
a giant, talking pig man, played by Stephen Graham, and real giants, and, of
course, Nazis, because there has to be Nazis. Lemire said, “Individually, Harbour
might have a humorous moment or two with his co-stars, but decreasingly so as
the movie staggers toward its messy, cacophonous end.”
This doesn’t seem to
end. After a really long two-hour runtime, “Hellboy” thinks that it will
hopefully be able to start its own franchise, but it might be stuck in
development instead.
I’m not going to say
that this remake is one of the worst I have seen, but definitely one that I was
disappointed in. It has been a while since I have been disappointed in a comic
book adaptation. It just felt like a mindless action flick that is stealing
elements from other movies and combining a lot of story lines. However, there
are some funny parts and Harbour does do a decent job, but I still think this
is one that you can wait until it comes out on Blu-Ray/DVD to rent it.
Alright, thank you for
joining in on this long review, stay tuned this Friday for the finale of “Edgar
Wright Month.”