My cousin is spending
his Spring Break over at my house, so my mother asked what he wanted to do.
When asked what movie he wanted to see in theaters, he said he had a few movies
he wanted to watch. I told him I already had seen “Logan,” “Kong: Skull Island”
and “Power Rangers,” he said he also wanted to see “Smurfs: The Lost Village,”
released on 7th. Since I was curious to see that one as well, we
went to see it. Since this is part of a franchise based on a cartoon that I
never saw, I think I should review the previous installments as well.
The only way I could
sum up the cartoon is that a village with small blue people fight off a wizard
and his cat. With that said, let’s take a look at the first “The Smurfs,”
released in 2011.
Even though the look is
different, “The Smurfs” isn’t as annoying as you think it would be and is
actually both charming and enjoyable, thanks to active animation, a strong
script, several good jokes and amazing performances from a nice cast.
Directed by Raja
Gosnell, “The Smurfs” is based on the Belgian comic strip characters created by
Peyo. When the evil but ridiculous wizard Gargamel (Hank Azaria) and his
equally evil but ridiculous cat Azrael (Frank Welker) find the village of the
Smurfs’ enchanted village, they accidentally chase six of them – Papa Smurf
(the late Jonathan Winters), Smurfette (the hot singer Katy Perry), Clumsy
Smurf (the late Anton Yelchin), Brainy Smurf (Fred Armisen), Gutsy Smurf (Alan
Cumming) and Grouchy Smurf (George Lopez) – through a magical portal that takes
every one of them to modern-day New York City.
Once there, the Smurfs
quickly become friends with pregnant housewife Grace (Jayma Mays) and her
stressed-out advertising executive husband Patrick (the man who played Doogie
Howser and Barney Stinson on “How I Met Your Mother,” Neil Patrick Harris), who
is struggling to come up with a new beauty campaign for his magnate boss Odile
(Sofia Vergara). As the Smurfs hide in Grace and Patrick’s apartment, Papa Smurf
quickly figures out that they have to get the power from the blue moon in order
to teleport back home, but Gargamel is closing in on them and wants to capture
their magical essence.
Hank Azaria is the
right choice as Gargamel (he looks exactly like the comic character) and fittingly
does the hilariously comic, Smurf-obsessed performance that’s the best to
watch. I agree with Matthew Turner when he said in his review, “There's also
strong, likeable support from Harris and Mays, while the voice cast acquit
themselves nicely – Perry proves she's more than just stunt casting as
Smurfette (one “I kissed a Smurf and I liked it” joke aside), while Winters is
suitably wise and unruffled as Papa Smurf and Yelchin does a good job with
making the potentially irritating Clumsy emotionally engaging.”
Turner goes on to say, “The
animation is extremely well done, capturing the feel of the source material and
nicely integrating the three-apples-high Smurfs into their New York
surroundings.” Similarly, Azrael is an entirely CGI-animated cat, which works
much better than you might think (a funny credit gives us that no CGI cats were
harmed during the filming of the movie).
Turner said, “The plot
may be fairly basic and it slightly overdoes both the pratfalls and the
sentimentality of the be-true-to-yourself message, but the clever script makes
up for it with several good jokes and some nice touches, such as Patrick and
Grace looking up Smurfs on Wikipedia.”
“The Smurfs” is an
enjoyable, well-made fantasy adventure that will attract children without
annoying their parents who they beg to watch it with them. Worth seeing,
although I understand if you may not be fond of it because it’s not for anyone.
“The Smurfs 2,”
released in 2013, is an enjoyable sequel to the first movie, brightened by
decent animation, strong comic performances, a nice voice cast and a funny,
nicely written script that says there is entertainment for both adults and
children.
Directed again by Raja
Gosnell, “The Smurfs 2,” begins with a brief recap of Smurfette’s origin
(pop-up book style), saying that she was created by Gargamel before Papa Smurf
turned her into a “true blue” Smurf using a magic spell that has Smurf essence.
However, unknowingly to
the Smurfs, Gargamel has created two new Smurf prototypes known as Naughties
and he sends one named Vexy, voiced by Christina Ricci, through a portal to
kidnap Smurfette and bring her to his Paris base, where he plans to harness the
secret of the magic spell for his own evil plans.
When the Smurfs see
that Smurfette is missing, Papa Smurf makes a rescue team with Grouchy, Clumsy
and Vanity, voiced by the host of “Last Week Tonight” on HBO, the great British
comedian John Oliver (one of my favorite comedians), and they transport themselves to New York to ask their
human friends Patrick and Grace to help them find Gargamel.
Turner is right when he
said, “Azaria was born to play Gargamel and he duly delivers another terrific
comic performance as the hapless wizard, while Winters (who sadly died after
filming was completed) is pitch-perfect as the perpetually unperturbed Papa
Smurf, and Perry does an excellent job of conveying Smurfette's emotional
conflict, torn between her creator, her new Naughty friends and her Smurf
family.” Similarly, Lopez, Yelchin and Oliver have a likable connection as the
rescuing Smurfs and the film also gives a welcome comic increase from Brendan
Gleeson, as Patrick’s well-meaning stepfather Victor, especially when he’s
accidentally turned into a talking duck.
Turner noted, “Gosnell's
experience with CGI/live action hybrids (e.g. Scooby Doo) makes him pretty much
the perfect director for the Smurfs franchise and the blending of live action
and animation is commendably seamless here, with the Paris locations used
inventively throughout. Similarly, the witty script is packed full of good
jokes (for both adults and children) and manages to deliver a strong message
(about the importance of any kind of family) without resorting to sickly
sentimentality.”
Turner noted, “The main
problem with the film is the depressing amount of completely unnecessary
product placement (especially considering the age of the film's target
audience) – prime offenders here include Gargamel learning how to use an iPad
and the Smurfs apparently having both the internet and ‘Smurfbook’, while the
aggressively pop-friendly soundtrack feels both distracting and out of place.”
Along with that, J.B.
Smoove’s Hackus (the other Naughty) is underdeveloped and never really becomes
a character, while the animation on the entirely-CGI cat Azrael (a deservingly
nice accomplishment) is once in a while a little scary.
“The Smurfs 2” is a pleasing
and enjoyable sequel that should attract both children and adults who are asked
to watch this with their children. Once again, I say you should see it, but if
you don’t like it, I completely understand.
Now with all of that
said, it’s time to talk about the latest in the franchise, “Smurfs: The Lost
Village,” which isn’t a sequel, but a restart to the series, especially since
they were planning a third movie, but cancelled it since Jonathan Winters has
passed.
How many times can you
go back to a seemingly creative place before it gets old? It looked like we had
done that with the Smurfs after the two previous films that had failed and didn’t
succeed in resurrecting the franchise.
Barbara VanDenburgh
stated in her review, “The prospect of a third film sounded less like a fun
family outing and more like a sociological experiment in pop-culture Stockholm
Syndrome.”
Thankfully, “Smurfs:
The Lost Village” is what the franchise needed in order to be fixed. It doesn’t
go anywhere near the bad idea of combining animation and live action and the
juvenile humor that no one really liked in the last two movies, and aims the
jokes and joys at the children audience. This fully animated reboot captures the
Smurfs Saturday morning cartoon roots and creates an energetic, brightly
colored, age-appropriate movie for children that are new to the Smurfs.
Smurfette, voiced this
time by the hot singer Demi Lovato, is the main character here. She’s going
through some sort of an existential problem. Originally created by evil wizard
Gargamel, voiced by Rainn Wilson, from a lump of blue clay, Smurfette isn’t
exactly like her members – she doesn’t even know if she can call herself a “real”
Smurf. In a village where everyone is named by their one characteristic – like her
friends Clumsy (Jack McBrayer), Brainy (Danny Pudi) and Hefty (Joe Manganiello)
– Smurfette is different.
While she’s thinking
where she belongs in Smurf Village (and anywhere in life), really close to the
wall that separates the Forbidden Forest she sees two big eyes and a little bit
of blue skin – a Smurf! However, the mysterious Smurf runs off into the
Forbidden Forest.
Meanwhile, Gargamel is
still really focused on his hunt for Smurfs, creating new evil plans to capture
the Smurfs and drain them of their essence. When Smurfette accidentally informs
Gargamel about the existence of a possible lost Smurf Village in the Forbidden
Forest, the wizard runs off to capture them. Smurfette must warn the Smurfs, so
she leaves with Clumsy, Brainy and Hefty through the area that is forbidden to
them to save them.
VanDenburgh credited, “The
animation is bright and simple, unsophisticated but not artless. The Forbidden
Forest is flush with creative, often treacherous flora and fauna, such as
fire-breathing dragonflies and bioluminescent “glow” bunnies.”
VanDenburgh assures, “Importantly,
this Smurfs adventure isn’t suffused in the sort of crude potty humor that has
become de rigueur. There’s a touch of it — butt-biting “bottom feeder” fish,
belching flowers, a noxious reference to underpants cheese — but mostly the
experience is pure. It’s also not drowning in anachronistic pop-culture
references, and the pop-song interludes are mostly harmless — except for a
remixed resurrection of Eiffel 65’s Europop hit “Blue (Da Ba Dee)” which is
better left buried in the ashes of the late ’90s.”
“Smurfs: The Lost
Village” keeps its focus on positive messages delivered by the main characters.
It’s a story about women in power, staying with your friends and making your
own mission in the world, regardless of who you are. It’s a kid’s movie happy
to be just that, and after the last two Smurf films, the serious ambition is a
welcome relief.
In the end, if you didn’t
like the last two Smurf movies, then definitely see this one. You will love it,
I promise you. As a matter of fact, I find all of these movies to be harmless, family fun films.
Thank you for joining
in on my review of the Smurfs movies. Stay tuned next Friday for the next
installment in “Jack Nicholson Month Part 2.”